A harrup SC would be no less / more reliable than any SC conversion. But it would have a lot of headroom for extra torque , whereas most are running the Eaton M62 flat-out , or even beyond its efficiency zone
what he means is it will be quieter than the m62 (as it's not screaming it's head off), and goes a lot quicker

I used mine as a daily for 8 years 6 of the s/c with both m62 then the harrop