Personal preferences, but I loathed mine with the hardtop on. Boomier inside, stayed colder for longer, not so quick/easy to whip off when the weather was good enough etc. with a properly looked after soft top they are no leaker than the ht.
Got to say, mine seems quieter with the hard top. That's being objective as I haven't done a noise test - perhaps I should. Also, don't know about colder for longer - can't say I notice a difference. If anything it's a bit warmer - maybe.
Have to agree about the wet though. My soft top doesn't leak at all.